Joan Jett’s Bad Reputation for a New Generation

Joan Jett on Stage in Concert

Can a Sears Christmas Catalog guitar make history? Is a 16 year old Runaway an icon? Is a bad reputation a female anthem? Did a fan of godmother of pop-punk change my life? If we are talking about Joan Fucking Jett, the answer is hell yes!

The Sears Wish List That Changed History

On a Christmas morning Joan Jett’s parents got her exactly what she wanted from the Sears Christmas catalog! A Silvertone electric guitar. This was what the 13 year old girl wanted for Christmas. In a time where women with guitars in pop music were relegated to acoustic guitars and folk rock, Joan wanted to shred. Joan wanted to fucking rock. A scant three years later, Joan and her Sears guitar would change history.

Runaways at CBGB’s

In 1975 Joan Jett would co found a band called The Runaways. She was 16. They did not talk about starting a band and play pretend in a garage, they started a rock band. By 1976 they were playing CBGB’s and touring the world.

They were huge in Japan, but they were also well known in the rest of Asia as well as Europe, Australia, Canada, and South America. They were headlining, but they were also opening for Cheap TrickRamonesVan Halen, and Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers. Cherry Bomb and other hits were known throughout the world, but not here in the U.S.

They were not able to capture the same level of success in the U.S. Just like we learned from the Tina Turner article here at Gen X Watch, America was not only reticent to welcome a strong black woman to the recording studios, they were not ready for women who could rock as hard as any band out there.

Unapologetic New Adventures

In 1979 the Runaways would break up. Joan was driven and immediately hit a studio in England with 2 members of the Clash to record 3 songs. One of which was an early rendition of what would become her infamous version of “I Love Rock and Roll”. She then went to LA to finish some contractual obligations with the now defunct Runaways.

Joan Jett took her share of the money and decided to start her band, the Blackhearts. She put an ad in the paper that said she was looking for 3 good men. She found them and they formed the band in 1979. From 1979 through 1981 it was a struggle. Then they would re record “I Love Rock and Roll” and that would put her on the charts for a lifetime and career that continues to this day.

Often called the godmother of pop-punk, her career includes 12 studio albums and 44 singles. She would also hit the top 100 18 times with a number 1 hit, star in the Movie “Light of Day” with Michael J Fox to critical acclaim, and even be the first rock artist to perform a concert on Broadway that also broke world records for swiftest sell out.

She did all of this on her terms!

Bad Reputation as an Anthem

Originally recorded independently, “Bad Reputation” would be re recorded in 1981 on the heels of “I Love Rock and Roll”. In an interview in 2021 celebrating the 40th anniversary of “Bad Reputation”, she would have this to say about the song:

“I’m kind of being sarcastic; my reputation; if it’s ‘bad,’ it’s for being strong, and my parents told me when I was five that I could be whatever I wanted as a girl, I could be anything. I believed them. I guess that is kind of the ‘bad,’ being able to say, ‘I’m gonna do what I want and you can’t tell me ‘no” – especially if I’m not hurting people. “I’m out here playing guitar, and you’re giving me grief for it, but you know, it’s much bigger than guitar. Like I said, when I was a kid, it was all about that, but now I realize it’s much more about other things.”

Jett became a feminist icon and her song went on to be an anthem for women of five generations. Having a bad reputation on your terms as you live your life and do not give a damn what others think.

I met a woman in 1991 who knew exactly what that song meant to her. It was much more and about other things.

Ohio

In the Summer of 1991 a girl I was crazy about broke up with me in a Dairy Queen parking lot. I was heartbroken at the time and took it hard. A friend of mine suggested we take a road trip to get out of my headspace. He had a cousin in Niles, Ohio we could visit. While there we found out Joan Jett and the Blackhearts were performing at the Eastwood Mall. We went. I met a girl with a bad reputation as defined by Joan Jett.

At the concert there was a woman that kept looking at me. She had jet black hair in a punk Siouxsie Sioux style, wearing a black leather biker jacket, spandex pants, studded belt, and had a nose ring with a chain attached that looped to her earring. She was short but her black heeled boots gave her an extra few inches and her bright red lipstick contrasted with her ice blue eyes and dark eye make up. Every time I looked over at her she was staring at me.

When Jett started playing Bad Reputation she came over to me and said, “This is my favorite! I’m Sarah.” I looked at her, smiled, and nodded. She stood next to me and was lost in the rest of the song with a hand in the air in a fist and belting out the lyrics.

After the song Sarah stared at me. I stared back. She spoke! “Dude, I’m trying to hit on you. Tell me you’re gay or have a girlfriend or I’m ugly or tell me your name.”

“I’m Pat! You’re gorgeous and I’m shy!”

“Wanna get out of here?” she smiled.

I told my buddy that I was heading out with Sarah so he’d have to go home with his cousin. I wouldn’t see my buddy ever again.

The Diner

Sarah and I got in my Thunderbird and went to a diner that served beer. We had beers and breakfast at midnight and started talking. She was 22. Only a year older than me and going pre med. Sarah told me that Bad Reputation was why she decided to become a doctor. She was originally set to be a nurse like her mom because her parents told her a girl could not be a doctor. She became a Joan Jett fan in middle school. Joan Jett rocking out in a man’s world and that song let her know she could be whatever she wanted to be and do whatever she wanted to.

She talked about her favorite bands and her dreams and her fears and her hopes.

I had never met a woman like her before. She was my age and was so sure and so free to be herself. I envied it. She also knew what she wanted, and that night she wanted me. She asked if I wanted to come to her apartment and spend the night. I really wanted to, but I was studying to be a minister and I also lived over 400 miles away. I told her both things in the lamest way possible.

“Pat, I like you. This is okay. This is okay. Take some time off from the world. If we still like each other in the morning, stay another day. I got a studio in Youngstown. Say yes.”

“Yes.”

Youngstown

I called my buddy from a phone booth outside the diner. I told him I would see him in a day or two. He told me to screw myself and he was taking a Greyhound back to Chicago if I really did this with THAT girl. He told me you have to be careful with women like THAT. She’s too forward and might have herpes.

She walked up to me in the phone booth and I felt a gentle kiss brush my lips as I was on the phone. She walked over to my car and lit a cigarette. I touched my lips and there was a hint of lipstick on my fingers. I told him I would pay him back for the bus ticket.

A few minutes later we would be in my T-Bird driving to Youngstown.

We smoked cigarettes and a joint on the way to her apartment and I felt her fingers intertwined in mine as she moved my hand to her knee.

Her apartment had a strat on a stand with an amp, an easel with a painting of the sea half done, compact stereo, and a mattress on the floor with an ashtray next to it. Her apartment smelled of cigarettes, weed, and lilacs.

Over the next 5 days we would feast on each other, get high, and talk. We talked about everything.

One night she took me out to meet some friends that were in a punk band. She jammed with them in a dive bar on an open mic night. She was amazing on the guitar as she did punk covers and I saw her as lost as she was at the concert, focused on the music.

So Much More!

In those 5 days I was fully myself for the first time since I was 9. I could just be me and she shared her life with me. She played her records for me. Joan Jett, Ramones, Runaways, Lita, Cyndi Lauper, Blondie, Heart and so much more. With the exception of the Ramones and the Clash it was all women rockers, punk and pop.

She told me about how feminism and suffrage inspired her as her only path to freedom from her dad’s drinking and abuse of her leading to her. She moved out the day she turned 18. Joined the reserves so she could get into school. She was raped during basic and persevered.

I got to hear her dreams and her heroes and how music and poetry freed her and showed her women can do whatever they want. They had to. Life on her terms was the only life worth living because she was never going back to the pain of her childhood marrying a man like her dad.

She went back to Joan Jett a few times. Sarah told me how Bad Reputation was her anthem as a girl in middle school. She was a new generation and she was gong to get out and do something with her life and help people.

This was my first time with a strong feminist at my age. I thought feminists had to be not feminine and maybe hate men or some other idiotic shit. No. She just had a strong sense of self and knew she had the same rights as anyone and was ready to stand up for herself so she could live her life on her terms.

She forever changed the way I saw women and my role in their lives.

Going Home

Day 5 I had to go home. I was starting a new semester in 2 days. She was starting a new semester in a few days as well. The last hour the weight of leaving was hanging over us. We lay in her bed holding each other not saying a word.

We walked to my car. She handed me Joan Jett’s “Up Your Alley” cassette and gripped my hand. I looked at her. “Sarah….” my heart was in my throat and I did not want to go. “I…” She shut me up with a kiss and there were tears in her eyes as she said through grit teeth,

“Don’t you dare fucking say it because then I’ll say it and this will suck more balls than it already does.”

I bit my lower lip and nodded.

“You could stay. Change your major.” She said. I shook my head still biting my lip.

“Need you to promise me something, Pat. Don’t become one of those religious jag offs that treats women like shit. My dad’s a pastor.”

We hugged for an eternity. Forever ended and I drove home.

I kept my promise, Sarah.

Every Feminist Friday is Dedicated to Erika

Photo of Erika with a cat

Erika died on Christmas leaving behind a family that has immediate needs.

Click here to read the story of how Erika saved my life when we were teenagers.

Click here to donate to the Gofundme a friend and local PRIDE organizer set up to help the family Erika was taken away from

Support Gen X Watch!

There are three ways you can do this:

1. Share this story with a friend and leave a comment.

2. Tip me! I do not have a contract with anyone in this work and for it to continue I need support.

3. Become a Members Only Patreon! In the Patreon I will have unfiltered rants, exclusive content, free PDF copies of the upcoming quarterly magazine, and more.

Thank you for your support and taking the time to read this.

Stay Totally Awesome! Stay true to you.

33 responses to “Joan Jett’s Bad Reputation for a New Generation”

  1. Jennifer Lindberg Avatar
    Jennifer Lindberg

    What a wonderful article. Made me really think about Joan Jett, whose strength made me uncomfortable as a young girl when she first came on the scene (mainstream I guess I should say). Why did it make me uncomfortable? Probably because I was a pre-teen in a Catholic school where everything JJ represented was frowned upon so it scared me. Years later I could see her for all she was, all she did, all she represented, and the ceilings she shattered.
    Sarah: What a wonderful moment in time!

    1. Pat Green Avatar

      Thank you for your comments. I wonder how many young women felt like you. When we are in the religious construct women of strength were intimidating to me. They had a “jezebel spirit”, but I never thought her strength and power could intimidate a young woman. Mind blown! Thank you!

  2. Scott Avatar
    Scott

    Another well written article, Pat. I must say, I feel like there’s another article waiting to be written about how such a good buddy who takes a road trip with you to help you get over a breakup can so quickly and easily turn on you and never be seen again.

    I also find it kind of sad that it always seems to take traumatic childhood events to make a woman into a feminist, to make her strong and self-sufficient, to make her determined and driven. Why can’t we live in a better world than that? Why can’t everyone just treat everyone else fairly, politely, positively? It really shouldn’t be that hard.

    Now you went and got me started.

    1. Pat Green Avatar

      My buddy was a Christian and in that culture you do not “yoke” with non believers. I sinned with a jezebel. As far as the rest. Mote thought later. I am at work. Thank you for reading and commenting.

    2. Pat Green Avatar

      I needed to revisit this when I hd more time. I am sure you remember the logic statements from school.
      Statement: “All squares are rectangles” True
      Converse: “All rectangles are squares.” False

      Most women have experienced some form of marginalization. And if we go by the traumatic we are looking in the US of Over 1 in 3 women (35.6%) have experienced rape, physical violence, and/or stalking by an intimate partner in their lifetime.SO I do not see a causal relationship between feminism and trauma.

      Many people who experience abuse do not know it is abuse because you are groomed. Think about gaslighting. Now, imagine if you come across some information after a lifetime of conditioning and you learn that you are a victim and you take the herculean steps to free yourself from the abuse and work on recovery from the trauma. You may find yourself seeking avenues to solidify your rights once you find out you have rights. You discover feminism where there are other people fighting for the same things and the same rights with the same ideals.

      Then you have people who were raised in a proper environment like Joan Jett was with parents that encouraged her from a young age that she could be anything and do what she wants in this life and gender is not a limitation. When she started the Runaways, they had a sexually predatory producer. She knew what he was and that it was not okay because it was infused at a young age.

      I hope I am explaining this well. Most women experience marginalization, even feminists.

      In the case of Sarah you have someone who lived an experience with a om not pushing back on her dad’s behavior. Her terror was normalized. Then music and poetry exposed her to the beginnings of philosophies that say…no…this is not okay and we can all work together to help each other.

      I am a feminist because I care about women and their rights. And I feel I have a responsibility since my evangelical ways were contributory to the harm in this society.

      I wish equality were not so enmeshed in political parties. I think there would be more conservative and christian feminists if a conversation could be had. Equality and equal protections for all just makes sense from a moral and even constitutional level.

  3. Sue Avatar

    Wow! Intense emotions there. I love Joan Jett. She was the bad girl hiding inside each of us. The confidence in me eventually came out thanks to women like her.

    1. Pat Green Avatar

      That is amazing to hear. Isnt it something how entertainers are more?

  4. Tawn Makela Avatar

    Thank you for the lovely trip down memory lane, my friend. I think you hit this one out of the park.

    1. Pat Green Avatar

      T means a lot. Thank you. Any artists from the day inspire you? Women?

  5. Dùghlas Avatar
    Dùghlas

    may i embrace the Bad Reputation!

    what a great model for women everywhere! go raibh maith agat (thank you) for the story about this queen of pop-punk.

    1. Pat Green Avatar

      She struck a nerve. A very powerful nerve. Thank you for commenting.

  6. Tracy Byrd Dickerson Avatar
    Tracy Byrd Dickerson

    Great story, Pat. I’m grateful you shared it.

    1. Pat Green Avatar

      Thank you for the kind words and taking the time to read and comment,

  7. Chris Avatar
    Chris

    Great stuff again, friend. Powerful.

    1. Pat Green Avatar

      I appreciate that. Thank you!

  8. Jen Finstrom Avatar
    Jen Finstrom

    Reading this on the bus this morning was such an inspiring start to the day! And I like to think I would have been friends with Sarah if I’d known her in those years. One of the things that stuck out most to me here was in the quote by Joan Jett that what she was doing wasn’t hurting people, so no one should be stopping her doing it. This brought back vivid high school memories of trying to explain to some peers and teachers that my dressing how I wanted and doing interesting things with eye make-up absolutely wasn’t hurting anyone and that self expression is a good thing. Thank you for this. It was inspiring on deeper levels as well, and I appreciate the interwoven stories here.

    1. Pat Green Avatar

      It is interesting who we would have and would have not gravitated toward in our youth. But to the bigger point, we do spend so much time micromanaging behaviors that are not hurting a damn soul and make it bad. And the things that do hurt others, seem to be the norm of the ones in power.

  9. Tracy S Avatar
    Tracy S

    Growing up, I thought Joan Jett was intimidating. But as I grew as a person, and a woman, I look up to her as a hero of a generation of women to take charge of who they are, and take no guff from anyone. I had the privilege of seeing her live a couple years ago, and still badass as ever. I still love rock and roll!

    1. Pat Green Avatar

      You are the second woman in the comments to say that she intimated you when you were younger. I find that fascinating. What about her made her so intimidating?

  10. Jennifer Runyon Avatar
    Jennifer Runyon

    So I’m a late Xer. When I was born (81) and all through school I was considered the last of gen x, then somewhere around the age of 23 when I was tagging on hipsters in high school, they stuck me into that same category and now I’m a millennial. Which I really is feel is a very gen x thing to have happen to you. Every generation you’ve been part of decides that you don’t belong with them and should find somewhere else. But I digress.

    I didn’t know Joan Jett, but I admired her and Pat Benetar, and Souixie Souix and all the women that wore leather jackets and smoked cigarettes. I did all that from within my little white dress wearing, Baptist church upbringing. I was confused at times. Like in 5th grade when the crisis pregnancy center came to talk to us, (no a typo, 5th grade) and brought stickers. I didn’t want any of them, not sure why, until I saw the one that said “EQUAL RIGHTS FOR UNBORN WOMEN”. lol yes, it makes me shudder today a bit but I also appreciate that I did not truly understand what it said at the time. What I do know is that none of the other kids wanted that one, I knew women should have equal rights all those women in leather jackets said so. FF to high school and I’m learning adversity. Still going to a Baptist school and church and disagree with a lot of things. It was the Riot Grrls that helped me be the only voice to speak out adamantly pro-choice. I failed an assignment bc I would not go and volunteer at the same crisis pregnancy center. I instead did the volunteer work after hours at a local DVI shelter my father did legal work for. It didn’t count for credit but that didn’t matter. Later in high school I was often the sole voice of choice pointing out the lack of humanity in their argument. I had a teacher fail me in her class for that reason (it was “Bible class”) but it didn’t matter because after all, that’s what the women in leather jackets would have done. I always admired them, the models, the musicians, the ones in my school older than me that accepted me among them and taught me tolerance. I always wanted to be them even though the scared me, the independence, they were their own authority, their own compass of right and wrong. They were kind, yet tough as nails.

    FF to today and I’m in my 40s. I’m a big woso (women’s soccer) fan and work in a supporters group for my local team. I lead the chants and pull the smoke grenades at goals. They asked to choose songs for warm ups for our team. Bad Reputation. That was my pick, I’m in front of about 100 or people when it usually plays and I rock out and dance on my small but lifted stand, while wear my denim sleeves once a jacked now a patched up vest (Florida summer is too hot for a leather jacket), and I hope I would make the women in leather jackets proud.

    1. Pat Green Avatar

      Jennifer Runyon Before I go any further, the phrase ” I admired her and Pat Benetar, and Souixie Souix and all the women that wore leather jackets and smoked cigarettes.” is pure genius and thank you for that!
      I also love that you invoked the Riot Grrls! I had to cut for space in the article, but Sarah exposed me to the concept of the Riot Grrls and when we think of not just the movement, but the artists like The Slits, Poly Styrene, Siouxsie Sioux, The Raincoats, Kim Gordon, Kim Deal, and of course, Joan Jett, you have a force of nature.
      I honestly do not think that punk culture gets the credit it deserves for the social advancement of women and feminism in the Riot Grrl movement. IMHO it was the etymology of 3rd wave feminism that needed to happen to address the problems with 2nd wave (and is still fighting the 2nd wave.
      Third-wave feminism gets that women are of many colors, ethnicities, nationalities, religions, cultural backgrounds, queer and trans. The riot grrl zines and music allowed women their own space to create music, publications and make political statements about the issues they were facing in the punk rock community and in society without the matriarchal hierarchy of 2nd wave. Every woman had a real voice. A voice that put patriarchy, double standards against women, rape, domestic abuse, sexuality, and female empowerment in a new light.
      God, you hit on so much with this post. Thank you!

      Also, I am sure the goddesses of smokes and leather approve!

  11. Allaina Humphreys Avatar
    Allaina Humphreys

    Joan Jett is my spirit animal. Thank you for writing about her through the lens of how actions and inspiration travel like flame – lighting up each person anew until the spark that started it is miles away from the forest fire that changes the landscape.

    1. Pat Green Avatar

      Fascinating! Honestly, I did not realize how deep her impact was until you and so many other women starting commenting here and in the Gen X Watch social media! It is one of the top 2 articles since we started.

  12. Arlene Avatar
    Arlene

    This is my favorite story thus far. I idolized Joan Jett and still do somewhat. She gave me strength.

    Thanks for sharing Sarah’s story.

    1. Pat Green Avatar

      Thank you for that. If you do not mind my asking, what got you about her? The response from women in regard to Joan Jett is overwhelming. I did not expect the response I am receiving on this one.

  13. […] I sat during his speech holding back tears. As the song played I stood with a fist raised in the air in the same way a woman I knew named Sarah did at a Joan Jett concert a lifetime ago. […]

  14. […] profound to on the surface as some of the groundbreaking things done by Cyndi Lauper, Tina Turner, Joan Jett, or Madonna. But for someone who felt lost and out of place, little things like that […]

  15. […] I write about Joan Jett, I am also writing about a woman named Sarah. When I write about Madonna I am also writing about a woman named Heather. The same is true of my […]

  16. […] never identified as a feminist. She lived her life on her terms. But her and Joan Jett showcased that there was not a lack of women in rock and punk, there was a lack of representation. […]

  17. […] and had read a lot of magazine articles about her and thought she was amazing. She was also into Joan Jett and […]

  18. […] most popular article in Gen X Watch about powerful women by a landslide is “Joan Jett’s Bad Reputation for a New Generation“. In the end of the article I make a woman named Sarah a promise that I would not treat women […]

  19. […] Hi Readers! Heather here breaking the 4th wall. Sarah from the Joan Jett article died in a car accident the day after thanksgiving. Pat fell hard and fast for her. It’s what […]

  20. […] had been back home in Illinois for a few days after meeting a woman named Sarah in Ohio at a Joan Jett Concert. Sarah and I spent five days, mostly in her studio apartment, exploring each other and life. The […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *